![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
Getting rid of the Wires: A problem Solved?A wireless speaker system is a great choice for anyone to get rid of unsightly and cumbersome wires trailing around the perimeter of a room between the receiver and the rear speakers in a surround sound installation. They also provide a simple alternative to in-wall wiring when extending that second pair of speaker outputs (Zone-B speaker outputs) on an AV receiver to a set of extra speakers elsewhere in the house. Yet, up to not long ago, performance of low cost wireless speakers has been rather disappointing. Problems related to powerline-induced hum, limited signal to noise ratio, limited audio frequency response, and signal dropouts due to interference from WI-FI networks, cordless phones, and microwave ovens, have often hampered the use of wireless speakers in the home. Besides, these systems would often introduce a perceptible latency delay between the front and the rear speakers that would throw out of synch the sound from the different channels. However, things have started to change, and they are changing rather fast! Thanks to advancement in wireless technology, wireless speaker systems have become more affordable and are getting better every day. It is partly for these reasons that they are becoming more popular with consumers. Modern RF-based systems use better transmitters and receivers to decrease the interference. Sound quality has improved to the point that it is close to CD-quality. In addition, setting up one of these systems is just a few minutes job - often all that it entails is to take them out of the box and turn them on. Admittedly, not all wireless speaker systems perform, and not all systems that perform come with an affordable price tag. The Rocketfish Wireless Speaker System reviewed here is an affordable wireless rear speaker kit that comes with a specs list that promises a lot for the price. So let's take a closer look... The Rocketfish RF-WHTIB Wireless Rear Speaker Solution
What the system does is to let you extend the rear surround to the back of the room via a set of 'virtual' wires. Basically, you are removing the connecting wires and instead replacing these with the wireless sender and receiver units to connect the outputs on the AV receiver with a pair of speakers placed up to 100 feet away. This range means that the Rocketfish wireless speaker system is also suitable to extend a second set of speaker outputs (commonly referred to as Zone-B speaker o/p on some AV systems), to an alternative room elsewhere in the house. Some may argue that this is not a true wireless system in that you still have wires running between the receiver unit and the two rear speakers. But the reality is that when it comes to wireless speakers, wireless does not mean 'wireless' - rather all that it means is less wires. And this applies also to the Rocketfish wireless speaker system. There are systems that include an independent wireless receiver/amplifier for each of the rear speakers; some also include a separate wireless subwoofer. However, these systems sell for more than double to three times the price of the Rocketfish wireless rear speaker kit since you are replicating the whole receiver end for each independent wireless speaker. You see, it is all a question of trade-offs. Yet the Rocketfish wireless speaker system still provides a solution to that primary hurdle many face when installing a surround sound speaker system - running speakers from front to back of the room. Simple to Install
This unit is powered by a 5-volts DC supply from the small AC adapter supplied with the Rocketfish wireless speaker kit.
The receiver unit measures 9" x 6½" x 1¾" - still relatively compact for a stereo amplifier capable of delivering 2 x 25W (RMS) into 4 ohms speakers. For a rear surround sound amplifier, that represents a lot of power, and can easily be matched with surround sound receivers having 80W (RMS) per channel for the main front left and right speakers. In other words, the stereo amplifier on the Rocketfish wireless speaker system can easily fill up a medium size room when used as part of a surround sound system. Note: If what you plan is a Zone-B installation, use only high quality passive speakers if you want to enjoy the very best sound out of this system. The stereo amplifier in the Rocketfish receiver unit can do a very good job in delivering high quality audio. This is one of the best wireless speaker systems we have come across. In fact, the audio quality from this Rocketfish wireless speaker system is so good that once installed, you would soon forget there are no wires in between! The receiver unit can be held in place horizontally on a level surface, vertically in the plastic holder provided (refer to picture above), or wall mounted using the two mounting holes on the bottom of the unit.
The receiver unit also incorporates a volume control to help balance the front and rear speakers in a surround sound setup. You do not need to keep adjusting the volume level every time you switch on the unit. It is just a one-time setting - you simply set the volume reference level such as to balance the rears with the rest of the speakers during initial setup. This is more of a 'trim' feature - often missing in most entry and mid-level HTIBs. When paired with such systems, the Rocketfish wireless speaker system would effectively be giving you the added facility to obtain a perfect match in the levels between the rear and front speakers. Once this setting is done, adjusting the volume control on your main system will then do it all; the Rocketfish wireless speaker system will still maintain a perfect balance between the rear and the front speakers at all volume levels. On the other hand, in a Zone-B installation, the volume control on the Rocketfish receiver unit can be used as a regular volume control to adjust the sound level as needed. Common to both the sender and the receiver units in the Rocketfish wireless speaker system, is the use of a 'soft' power switch, and a small manual connect button that may be used to restart the connection process. The use of the 'connect' button is just a last resort attempt to help establish communication in case the system fails to do so, on power up. The sender and receiver are pre-matched at the factory, so the connect buttons are there mainly for servicing reasons rather than anything else. In most cases, all that is necessary to start communication is simply to power up the units. Problems with establishing communication would possibly arise only if there is serious interference from other devices operating in the same 2.4Ghz frequency range. We have to say here that we did not encounter any such problems with the Rocketfish wireless speaker system on review. During the numerous tests that we conducted on the unit, it always established perfect communication on startup. And this despite the fact that the Rocketfish system was operating in an environment that included a wireless LAN and a cordless phone. At one point, we also switched on the microwave oven to further test the Rocketfish system's ability to maintain an interference-free connection. In this respect, the Rocketfish wireless speaker system has proved itself as one of the most bullet-proof wireless audio systems we have ever come across. This is all it takes to install the Rocketfish wireless speaker system; setting up the system on review was a few minutes job. The Rocketfish RF-WHTIB System in UseAs indicated earlier on, the Rocketfish system startup is a snap, and once set, you would soon forget that this is a wireless system. It just behaves as any other wired speaker system - irrespective of whether you are using it for the rear speakers, or as part of a Zone-B implementation. Interference and Range: The user manual indicates a maximum range of 100 feet. That leaves quite a few options open for the Rocketfish wireless speaker system when used as part of a Zone-B installation. In our case, we did not have the possibility to test the system at its maximum range. But we were quite close at about 85 feet between the sender and the receiver unit, a couple of walls and a floor away. No problems were encountered - sound quality was as if the sender and the receiver units were in the same room. As stated earlier on, the system uses 2.4 GHz wireless range to transmit the audio signal. We have a WLAN using 802.11b/g/pre-N gear; the sender unit was just a few feet away from the main router. There is also a wireless signal booster in another part of the house; this was just 30 feet away from the receiver unit when conducting the long range test. The use of the Rocketfish wireless speaker system did not affect in any way the performance of the WLAN, and the network speed was up as usual. Equally important...
We have used other wireless speakers systems in the past, but we were less than satisfied with their performance, with 2.4Ghz devices in the house causing all sort of interference problems, popping sounds, hissing noises, and the like. Nothing of this sort with the Rocketfish wireless speaker system. Audio Quality: The overall performance of the wireless audio link was very good for a $100 wireless rear speaker system. We still say 'wired is king' in the audiophile world, but...
Sure that this is just a $100 piece of gear, but irrespective of the price, and irrespective of being wireless or otherwise, the Rocketfish system compares favorable in any case. The stereo amplifier in the Rocketfish wireless system has a full 20-20,000Hz frequency response, and the system transmits uncompressed digital audio using 16-bit 48KHz audio over the wireless link. This is the same as CD-audio quality. This makes the system suitable for both surround sound in movie watching as well as for 5.1 multi-channel music listening. Theoretically, a 16-bit sample in the digital audio bit-stream can support a theoretical dynamic range of 96dB between floor noise and the loudest sound that the system can handle. In simple terms, this represents the signal to noise level. The Rocketfish system supports a signal to noise ratio of 87dB. Most entry to mid-range level HTIB systems support similar signal to noise ratio levels over their audio power outputs. System Latency Delay: Minimizing latency (unwanted time delays) is important when using a wireless rear speaker system in a surround sound setup to ensure that all audio channels stay in synch. The Rocketfish wireless speaker system has a transmission delay of less than 20msec, which is well within the typical delay settings normally applied for the rear channels.
This delay issue is irrelevant when the Rocketfish wireless speaker system is used to route stereo sound to a secondary room in the house. ConclusionWe were quite happy with the performance of the Rocketfish wireless speaker system on review. No complaints what so ever. Rather, it has changed our way of looking at wireless speaker systems as part of a surround sound setup. Until we got the unit for review from Best Buy, we were rather reluctant on using wireless speaker systems as part of a multi-channel audio installation. But that's no more. True that 'wired' is still king and no one should expect the ultimate from a $100 wireless system. But a wireless speaker system like the Rocketfish RF-WHTIB kit would surely do a great job in many audio installations while taking away the nightmare many face when running speaker wires. No more need to rip up carpets, cut holes in drywall, or chasing bricks to hide speaker wires! If this is your problem, then it is time to check out the Rocketfish wireless speaker system. This wireless rear speaker kit is covered by a one-year parts and labor warranty. Furthermore, the fact that it comes from Best Buy means that it should prove easy to return and get your refund in the unlikely event that there is a problem. Review Update: 26th June 2007Simple Fix to Buzzing Noise Problem on some AV Systems. Following the publication of this RocketFish wireless speaker system review in May, we did receive - among the numerous positive feedback - a few complaints about a noise problem some encountered on their AV system when using the Rocketfish wireless rear speaker kit. Although we did not experience any problem with the Rocketfish wireless speaker system during the review, yet we decided to investigate further. The problem concerns the presence of hum on the rear speakers connected to the RocketFish receiver unit when switching off the AV receiver. This leads to the inconvenience of having to switch off the RocketFish once the AV system is put on standby. This hum problem may also appear when the AV receiver is switched on and the rear channel signal level is low. It was not easy replicating the problem at our end. For the review, we used a typical compact HTiB system, and as stated, no problems what-so-ever. We used the HTiB because of practical reasons - it was just easy to move around. We decided to connect the Rocketfish wireless speaker system with a high-end but rather 'oldish' Marantz AV receiver. And... the noise problem emerged! Back to the HTiB, hum disappeared. It seemed as if this was a mismatch issue. Checking online revealed a blog thread at alivematters.wordpress.com, proposing a simple inexpensive fix - namely to load the rear speaker outputs on the AV system, each with a 100-ohm 1W resistor (you need two such resistors - one for each rear channel). Technically this makes sense. While with some audio systems, an open circuit on the speaker outputs would not matter, yet with others, an open circuit would throw the system into all sorts of problems. The impedance of the RocketFish sender unit is 6.6K - almost an open circuit for an amp designed to drive a 4 to 8 ohm speakers. Loading the rear speaker outputs on the AV with a 100-ohm resistor did work fine. The value of the load resistors is not critical. Just try not to go much above the 100-ohm - preferable lower but then take care about the power rating of the resistor since lowering the resistor would require a higher rating. The 100-ohm seems the ideal balance. The 1 Watt rating is based on a one-to-one power amplification. It is being assumed that you have set the volume on your Rocketfish unit to deliver a full 25W when the AV receiver is delivering approximately the same amount of power into a set of wired 4-ohm rear speakers. If your system rating is designed to deliver 25W into 8 ohms instead, the power rating of the resistors should be 2 Watts. Take care that as you increase the resistor rating, it starts to get really hot - so check this out after a first movie. These resistors are inexpensive and should be readily available. However, if this resistor issue is turning out to be complicated electronics, we suggest to call Rocketfish Customer Support on 1-800-620-2790. They should send you a free modified speaker lead to use as a replacement to the original 2ft speaker wire included with the RocketFish wireless speaker system, i.e. the speaker lead used to connect your AV system with the RocketFish sender unit. Note: This noise problem has already been fixed on the new batches of RocketFish wireless speaker systems - so no such modification is required with any new purchase.
|
Copyright © - Practical-Home-Theater-Guide.com All rights reserved. |
||||||||||||||||||
|
Original Review Date:
Last Update: Lots more info at Practical Home Theater Guide Suggested Further Reading:
Wireless Home Theater: A buying guide to Wireless
Speakers Systems
PC - Home Entertainment Integration through Wireless Media Players
A Practical Guide to Wireless Headphones and Dolby
Headphone technology
Surround Sound
Formats Speaker Placement in Multi-Channel Audio Correct home theater speaker placement plays a critical role towards achieving that seamless ‘enveloping’ sound so important in the overall home theater experience.
Time Delay
Settings in Surround Systems
Home
Theater Equipment Placement
Selecting and Installing Speaker Wire
Home Theater Design:
Home Theater Room Design Basics (1):
Room Acoustics and Lighting
Set-up Discs and Video Calibration Solutions
Quick
Guide to DVI
HDMI
Cable Guide
HDCP and HDTV:
Audio Video
Equipment Racks
A Quick Guide to A complete e-Book on how to research, design and build your own Home Theater. by Duncan McClelland
Wireless Speaker Kits @
Rocketfish Universal Wireless
Rear Speaker Kit
RCA 900MHz Wireless Speakers (Pair)
Acoustic Research 900MHz Wireless Stereo Speakers with Auto Tuning
|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||